TIMESTAMPS
Part 1
00:00 – Introduction to Debate (Overview of Nature, Subject Matter, and Speakers)
02:28 – Details Regarding Subject Matter and Format
03:40 – First Speaker (Muftī Taha Karaan) Regarding the Distortion of the Qurʾān
04:15 – Why Start with the Topic of the Qurʾān’s Distortion?
05:52 – The Transmission and Authenticity of the Qurʾān from the Perspective of the Twelvers
09:35 – Second Speaker (Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini) Regarding the Distortion of the Qurʾān
11:35 – The Effects of the Iranian Revolution (1979) on the Sunnī-Shīʿī Split
17:43 – Response to the Question of the Authenticity of Qurʾān According to the Shīʿah
25:18 – Muftī Taha Karaan Responds to Dr. Husseini Regarding the Authenticity of the Qurʾān According to the Shīʿah
28:45 – Muftī Taha Karaan Reads from Shīʿī Texts as Proof for his Arguments
37:23 – Muftī Taha Karaan Names Scholars from the Shīʿah Who Believed the Qurʾān was Distorted
40:23 – Muftī Taha Karaan Explains Why the Shīʿah Have Not Printed Another Version of the Qurʾān Whilst Believing in its Distortion
42:35 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini Responds to Muftī Taha Karaan’s Claim Regarding the Shīʿah’s Belief in the Distortion of the Qurʾān
Part 2
00:00 – Muftī Taha Karaan Responds to Sayyid Abdullah Husseini’s Rejection of the Shīʿah’s Belief in the Distortion of the Qurʾān
00:55 – Muftī Taha Karaan Explains the Issue of al-Sayyārī, the Shīʿī Narrator Cursed by Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq
09:43 – Muftī Taha Karaan Responds Regarding a Ḥadīth Narrated by Ibn Masʿūd Rejecting Chapters of the Qurʾān
11:19 – Muftī Taha Karaan Lists the Names of Shīʿī Scholars Who Held the Position That the Qurʾān is Distorted
12:40 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini Responds to Mufti Taha’s Rebuttal Regarding the Distortion of the Qurʾān
20:25 – Muftī Taha Karaan’s Final Remarks on the Distortion of Qurʾān in Response to Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini
25:33 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini’s Final Remarks on the Distortion of the Qurʾān
Part 3
00:00 – The Authority of Ahl al-Bayt in Light of the Qurʾān and Sunnah
00:55 – First Speaker (Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini) Presents Proofs for the Authority of Ahl al-Bayt from the Qurʾān and the Sunnah
15:03 – Second Speaker (Muftī Taha Karaan’s) Response Regarding the Authority of the Ahl al-Bayt
19:05 – A Cardinal Rule Regarding the Interpretation of the Qurʾān (Muftī Taha Karaan)
21:40 – What is Meant by Ahl al-Bayt? A Qurʾānic Answer (Muftī Taha Karaan)
24:24 – A Note Regarding the Sequence and Placement of Qurʾānic Verses (Muftī Taha Karaan)
25:10 – A Linguistic Principle Regarding Gender Usage in the Arabic Language in Response to the Interpretation of the Verses Regarding Ahl al-Bayt (Muftī Taha Karaan)
26:15 – A Ḥadīth Explaining Who the Ahl al-Bayt Are (Muftī Taha Karaan)
Part 4
00:00 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini Responds to Muftī Taha Karaan Regarding the Authority of the Ahl al-Bayt
00:46 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini Explains the Types of Will in Relation to Allah
03:15 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini Explains the Types of Filth Which Allah Removes from the Ahl al-Bayt
11:25 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini Explains the Meaning of “Ahl” as Used in the Qurʾān
13:55 – Muftī Taha Karaan Responds to Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini’s Interpretation of Verses in the Qurʾān Regarding “Ahl“
16:24 – Muftī Taha Karaan’s Response Regarding a Ḥadīth Quoted by Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini About the Ahl al-Bayt
17:18 – Muftī Taha Karaan Addresses the Issue of Types of Filth as Mentioned by Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini
20:53 – Muftī Taha Karaan Speaks About the Acceptance of the Prayer of the Prophet ṣallaLlāhu ʿalayhi wa sallam and the Fallibility of the Ahl al-Bayt
22:05 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini’s Final Remarks Regarding the Ahl al-Bayt
28:19 – Muftī Taha Karaan’s Final Remarks Regarding the Ahl al-Bayt
30:50 – Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini Responds to the Ḥadīth that Exclude the Wives of the Prophet ṣallaLlāhu ʿalayhi wa sallam from the Ahl al-Bayt
36:06 – Muftī Taha Karaan Responds to Dr. Sayyid Abdullah’s Remarks Regarding the Ḥadīth Excluding the Wives of the Prophet ṣallaLlāhu ʿalayhi wa sallam from the Ahl al-Bayt
38:55 – Questions and Answers Regarding the Distortion of the Qurʾān and the Ahl al-Bayt
44:50 – Question Regarding the Fallibility of the Companions and Verification of Ḥadīth in the Sunnī World (Muftī Taha Karaan)
48:42 – Question Regarding the Purification of the People of Badr Who Fled at Uḥud (Muftī Taha Karaan)
51:12 – Question Regarding the Abrogated Verse of Stoning Mentioned by ʿUmar raḍiyaLlāhu ʿanhu (Muftī Taha Karaan)
52:54 – Question Regarding the Shīʿah Having a Different Qurʾān (Muftī Taha Karaan)
54:41 – Question Regarding ʿĀʾishah (raḍiyaLlāhu ʿanhā) and Sayyid Abdullah’s Stance on Her (Dr. Sayyid Abdullah Husseini)
57:50 – Question Regarding the Significance in the Placement of the Verses of Purification (Muftī Taha Karaan)
59:20 – Question Regarding the Consequences of the Debate as Far as the Unity of the Muslims is Concerned and Their Stance Against the Enemies of Islam
1:06:10 – Question Regarding the Ḥadīth on the Two Things Left Behind by the Prophet ṣallaLlāhu ʿalayhi wa sallam